There was a time when I could never get rid of the hole in bread, no matter how hard I tried. For this, I have searched a lot, read many recipe books, and asked many people. But to no avail until the day I met my old friend Mac.
Mac is a childhood friend of mine who is now the head chef of a renowned bakery in New York. Finally, he rescued me from this hole-in-bread problem. He told me to find the causes which I did, and successfully met with the solutions.
And so to push your sufferings away, now I am going to share with you those easy but beneficial ideas with proper instruction that I and Mac developed to bake without large hole-in-bread. So, why wait? Let’s dig in.
Hole in Bread
A hole in bread means empty spaces or you can call it having air pockets in your loaf. These holes are created by the trapped CO2 bubbles and can be shaped in many sizes. They can be small, big, or uneven. There is nothing to panic about because this is normal while you are baking bread. This usually occurs because of a combination of factors during your bread-making process.
Some Common Examples of Hole in Breads
Fig 1- Breads with holes
If you are worried about holes in bread, then just look at these most common and tasty breads from below which are intentionally baked to have holes in ‘em.
1. Artisanal Breads
These breads have irregular air pockets due to their extended fermentation and unique handcrafted baking technique. And the holes are the reason behind artisanal bread’s rustic look and prominent chewy texture.
2. Sourdough Breads
Sourdough breads are another example of bread with holes. They are made of wild yeast that creates holes inside of the bread during fermentation. And that is pretty natural because these breads are mainly popular for their hole-filled structure.
3 High-Hydration Doughs
A dough with a higher water content can build big air pockets during the fermentation process. You must have eaten these types of bread like ciabatta, baguette and many more. Every one of them has large holes in them.
Apart from these examples, various kinds of bread have holes. So, thinking about it will make you laugh after a while if you know the rest about this “hole in bread” thing. So keep digging.
What Causes Holes In Bread
Fig 2 – Causes of hole in bread.
You have pockets, that’s why your bread has pockets too. Okay, sorry for the bad joke though. There are several factors that work behind creating holes in your bread. One of them is the activity of yeast during the fermentation process. But this is not the end. There is more. So, what are they? Okay then, let’s explore the common reasons behind those airy pockets in the following section.
1. Uneven Yeast Distribution
The uneven distribution of yeast can create Air Holes or Tunnels Inside your bread. This occurs because yeast is a microorganism that produces carbon dioxide gas and metabolizes sugar in the dough. So when you are mixing yeast unevenly, some parts of your dough encounter higher yeast activity while other areas may have less. This means you are baking a dough that will have some hollow portions while the others are very firm. Which will make your bread look weird obviously.
2. Improper Dough Handling
You have to handle your dough properly to prevent holes in the bread. Here yeast activity is very related to dough handling. How? Well, while you are going through the shaping process your roughly handled dough can cause irregularities in the fermentation system. That can yield a crooked distribution of yeast. And you know the rest of what happened when it occurred from our previous point. So improper dough handling can introduce holes in your bread for sure.
3. Incorrect Proofing
Be cautious about proofing your dough for too long because that can let the yeast do overwork which can trap air in large amounts inside of your bread. And if it occurs that means your bread has now big gas bubbles. When those bulges escape your bread will have enormous holes.
On the other hand, if you don’t proof the dough with enough time the yeast will not work properly and the bread will be dense and have few or no holes.
Sometimes, there is a chance that incorrect proofing can contribute to bread molding more quickly. In that case, check this How To Keep Bread From Molding? – The Complete Guide To Save Better and avoid quick molding.
4. Baking at the Wrong Temperature
At the beginning of the baking process if you don’t bake your bread at a high temperature your bread will not get enough heat. This will trap the bubbles inside the dough. And while you are baking, those bubbles will grow too much. As a result, the outside of your bread will not get strong enough. And bread with weaker outside doesn’t expand properly. So, this situation will definitely create uneven holes in your bread.
5. Inaccurate Hydration Level
Inaccurate hydration in dough can also develop large holes in your bread. If you pour too little water you will get a dense texture while too much water can lead to a gummy interior in your bread. If you want an even crumb structure and balanced crust you have to ensure proper hydration.
Hence, these are the most common reasons behind having holes in bread. As you have witnessed them, now you can simply avoid these factors to have a well-structured bread.
And if you want to dodge the causes of hole-in-bread properly, then this below “Solution” topic can help you with that. So, let’s dig in.
What are the Solutions for Controlling Holes in Bread?
Fig 3 – Solutions of hole in bread
When I was surfing the internet to learn the solutions for controlling holes in bread, I found out a lot of information. But the problem I faced is that only some of them work properly.
Then I decided to do some homework and with the help of my chef friend, whom I mentioned at the beginning of the article, discovered that not only does choosing the right flour matter, but there are several factors also.
So together we made some real-time solutions. To avoid this hole-in-bread issue, you can use those exciting keys. Let’s take a look.
1. Use the Correct Types of Flour
Using the bread flour is a tricky shot. Why? Because it contains a higher protein content than all-purpose flour. Those proteins can build a stronger gluten network which deducts the size and the number of holes in the bread.
Other minerals like calcium and magnesium can also affect the performance of yeast and enzymes. So, if you want to regulate the fermentation process for baking a well-structured crumb without large holes, then bread flour is a wise option.
2. Knead the Dough Properly
After choosing the right flour the next thing you need to look at with care is the kneading process. The development of gluten is directly connected with kneading which gives bread its structure.
Therefore if you don’t knead properly then your dough is going to be weak and fail to hold its exact shape. And the result is you will have large uneven holes in your bread. In contrast, over-kneading can also bring you disappointment because it makes your ao tough and dense.
3. Proof the Dough Rightly
And now that you have kneaded your dough properly it’s time to proof the dough in the right way. As you know, the proofing process allows the yeast to ferment and produce carbon dioxide gas. And this gas is the creator of the hole in bread.
So it is important to make sure that your dough has been proofed enough. Otherwise, your dough will ferment without enough gas, and that will create undesired holes in your bread. Over-proofing the dough is also an incorrect process. It will force your dough to collapse, and that will make large holes.
4. Degass Smoothly
If your dough has fermented well then the next step is degassing. You have to gently degas the dough. Generally, professional bakers use it to ensure that any larger bubble is evenly distributed in the dough or not. This is an easy but important technique you can follow to bake your dough with even holes too.
You can learn more about how to degass your dough by watching this The perfect loaf: degassing is the key? to crack the science of regular or irregular hole in bread.
5. Adjust Oven temperature and Steam Perfectly
To bake your bread without unwanted large holes you need to know what temperature is best for your dough. It’s the last but the most vital process. Before you put the dough inside the oven make sure that you have preheated it. Because when you put the dough in a hot oven, the yeast starts its final work. Through this process, your bread will rise properly.
Now, set your oven at around 425-475°F or 220-245°C temperature. It will help to set the crust quickly. This over-spring process stops the expansion of the outer layer of your dough before the activity of yeast comes to an end. It traps the steam inside of your dough and shows up with a compact loaf with a crisp crust which means no larger hole in bread has been created inside.
Therefore, you can follow these simplest steps to control the hole in the bread. But if you are an amateur don’t expect to have a good result while you are trying it for the first time. With a few attempts and patience, you can master the art of controlling the hole in bread entirely.
Is Hole in Bread Poisonous
Fig 4 – Fresh bread with holes
Don’t worry buddy! Hole in bread is not poisonous and does not contain any inherent toxicity or health hazards.
The presence of holes in your bread means you are going to have a well-made bread that has been properly fermented. It’s a natural thing that happens because of the bread-making process.
However, if you find any unusual color or off smells inside of your dough then just check this Does Dough Go Bad? How To Know When To Throw It Out before you take any action. Otherwise, you can consume bread with holes without any doubt.
FAQs
What is hole in bread?
A hole in bread means having undesirable gaps that form while you are baking your bread. Naturally, this happens when your dough doesn’t rise evenly.
Why do some types of bread have more holes than others?
Having more or fewer holes depends on various factors such as dough consistency, yeast kneading, and different types of baking techniques. As you know ciabatta has larger holes, while sandwiches have denser ones. This difference occurred because of their intended texture.
Is it safe to eat bread with a large hole in the center?
Yes! It is safe to eat bread with a large hole in the center. As hole in bread occurs due to the trapped air inside of your dough or uneven rising during the baking process it’s totally safe to have bread with holes.
Conclusion
In conclusion, a hole in bread is as good as having a window in your room. There is no reason to worry about it. It’s just a byproduct of your bread-making process that happens due to several factors like yeast activity, dough handling, proofing, and baking temperature.
As we have danced together over the whole article, I hope you got a clear idea about what the reasons behind these holes in your bread are, as well as how to control them. Now you just have to keep practicing because practice makes perfect.
So don’t let the hole in the bread irritate you anymore. Be the master and control them as you want.
More Resources
How Long is Bread Good for After the Expiration Date: Everything You Need to